Cloud Build vs. Docker: Unveiling the Ultimate Containerization Contender

I had this question when I was first learning about YAML, Docker, and containers. The question is, can Docker be fully replaced by using GCP only? The answer? Yes and no.

No, Cloud Build is not a replacement for Docker. Docker and Cloud Build serve different purposes in the context of containerization.

Docker is a containerization platform that allows you to build, run, and manage containers. It provides tools and features to package applications and their dependencies into container images, which can then be run on different systems. Docker enables you to create and manage containers locally on your development machine or in production environments.

On the other hand, Cloud Build is a managed build service provided by Google Cloud Platform (GCP). It focuses on automating the build and testing processes of your applications, including containerized applications. Cloud Build integrates with various build tools and can be used to build and package your applications, including container images, in a cloud environment. It provides scalability, resource management, and automation capabilities for your build workflows.

While Cloud Build can help you automate the creation of container images, it does not provide the full functionality of Docker as a containerization platform. Docker encompasses a wider range of features, such as container runtime, container orchestration, container networking, and image distribution.

BUT I JUST NEED TO BUILD AND STORE CONTAINER IMAGES!

Well, in that case, then yes, if your primary need is to build container images and store them, then Cloud Build can serve as a viable solution without requiring you to use Docker directly.

Cloud Build integrates with Docker and provides a managed build environment to automate the process of building container images. You can…

1. Define your build steps in a configuration file,
2. Specify the base image, dependencies, and build commands, and
3. Cloud Build will execute those steps to create the desired container image.

Additionally, Cloud Build can push the resulting container images to a container registry, such as Google Container Registry or any other Docker-compatible registry, where you can store and distribute the images.

By using Cloud Build for building and storing container images, you can take advantage of its managed environment, scalability, and automation capabilities without needing to manage your own Docker infrastructure.

WHAT IF I JUST WANT TO BUILD A SIMPLE CONTAINER IMAGE?

Yes, you can create a container image that runs code to call an external API, fetch data, process it, and store it using Cloud Build without Docker. Cloud Build provides the necessary tools and infrastructure to build container images based on your specifications.

To create a container image with Cloud Build, you would typically define a build configuration file, such as a `cloudbuild.yaml` file, that specifies the steps and commands to build your image. Here’s an example of a simple `cloudbuild.yaml` configuration:

steps:
- name: 'gcr.io/cloud-builders/docker'
args:
- 'build'
- '-t'
- 'gcr.io/YOUR_PROJECT_ID/your-image-name:latest'
- '.'
- name: 'gcr.io/cloud-builders/docker'
args:
- 'push'
- 'gcr.io/YOUR_PROJECT_ID/your-image-name:latest'

In this example, the configuration file instructs Cloud Build to use the Docker builder image to build and push the container image. You can customize the configuration to include additional steps, such as installing dependencies, copying source code, and executing the necessary commands to call the external API and process the data.

Let’s dissect this piece of code to see what it’s all about.

• The steps section is where you define the sequence of build steps to be executed.
• The first step uses the gcr.io/cloud-builders/docker builder image, which contains the necessary tools for working with Docker.
• The name field specifies the name of the builder image.
• The args field specifies the arguments to be passed to the builder image. In this case, it performs a Docker build operation.
• -t flag specifies the tag for the container image.
• 'gcr.io/YOUR_PROJECT_ID/your-image-name:latest' is the tag for the container image. You should replace YOUR_PROJECT_ID with your actual project ID and your-image-name with the desired name for your image.
• '.' indicates the current directory, which is the context for the build. It means that all files and directories in the current directory will be included in the build context.
• The second step uses the same gcr.io/cloud-builders/docker builder image.
• The args field specifies the arguments for the builder image. In this case, it performs a Docker push operation.
• The 'gcr.io/YOUR_PROJECT_ID/your-image-name:latest' specifies the container image to be pushed to the container registry.

By executing these steps in the Cloud Build pipeline, the Docker build command is triggered, which builds the container image using the specified Dockerfile and other files in the build context. Once the image is built, the Docker push command is executed to push the image to the specified container registry, making it available for deployment.

Remember to replace YOUR_PROJECT_ID with your actual project ID and your-image-name with your desired image name. Additionally, you would need to set up the necessary Dockerfile and any code or scripts required for your specific use case.

Note: This is a basic example, and depending on your specific requirements, you may need to include additional steps or modify the configuration to suit your needs.

Once you have defined your build configuration, you can trigger a build using Cloud Build. It will execute the build steps specified in the configuration and create the container image based on your code and dependencies. The resulting image can be stored in a container registry, such as Google Container Registry, where it can be accessed and deployed.

Keep in mind that Cloud Build focuses on the build process itself, so you will need to include the necessary code and logic within your container image to call the external API, fetch data, process it, and store it. Cloud Build provides the infrastructure for building and storing the image, but the actual functionality and behavior of the containerized code should be implemented within the image itself.

However, it’s important to note that Cloud Build is primarily focused on the build process and may not provide the full range of features and flexibility that Docker offers as a comprehensive containerization platform. If you require advanced functionalities like container runtime, container orchestration, networking, and image distribution, you may still need to use Docker in conjunction with Cloud Build or explore other containerization solutions like Kubernetes.

I’M STILL CONFUSED. WHAT CAN DOCKER DO THAT CLOUD BUILD CAN’T?

Docker and Cloud Build serve different purposes and have different functionalities. Here are a few things that Docker can do that Cloud Build does not provide:

1. Container Runtime: Docker provides a container runtime environment, which allows you to run and manage containers on your local machine or in a production environment. It includes features like container creation, starting, stopping, and managing container processes.

2. Container Orchestration: Docker has built-in container orchestration features through Docker Swarm and Kubernetes. It allows you to deploy and manage containerized applications across multiple machines, ensuring scalability, load balancing, and fault tolerance.

3. Container Networking: Docker provides networking capabilities that allow containers to communicate with each other and with the outside world. It enables you to define and manage networks for your containers, set up port mappings, and control network access.

4. Image Distribution: Docker offers a centralized registry called Docker Hub, where you can store, share, and distribute container images. It allows you to push and pull images to and from the registry, making it easy to distribute your applications across different environments.

5. Image Management: Docker provides features for building, tagging, and versioning container images. It allows you to create customized images, manage image layers, and efficiently update and maintain your containerized applications.

Cloud Build, on the other hand, is primarily focused on the build and continuous integration/continuous deployment (CI/CD) process. It helps automate the building, testing, and packaging of your code into container images, which can then be deployed using other tools or platforms like Kubernetes Engine or Cloud Run.

While Docker is a powerful containerization platform with a broader range of capabilities, Cloud Build complements it by providing an infrastructure for automating the build process and integrating it into your CI/CD workflows on Google Cloud Platform.

It’s important to note that Docker can be used in conjunction with Cloud Build. You can use Cloud Build to build your Docker images and push them to a container registry, and then use Docker to manage the runtime, orchestration, networking, and distribution of those images in your desired environment.

INTERESTING.. WHAT CAN CLOUD BUILD DO THAT DOCKER CAN’T?

Cloud Build offers several features and capabilities that Docker does not provide:

1. Scalable and Managed Build Environment: Cloud Build provides a scalable and managed build environment in the cloud. It automatically provisions the necessary resources to perform your builds, eliminating the need for you to manage and maintain your own build infrastructure.

2. Integration with CI/CD Pipelines: Cloud Build integrates seamlessly with other CI/CD tools and services, such as Cloud Source Repositories, GitHub, and Bitbucket. It allows you to trigger builds automatically whenever changes are made to your source code repository, enabling continuous integration and deployment workflows.

3. Build Configurations as Code: With Cloud Build, you define your build configurations using a simple YAML-based configuration file. This allows you to version control and manage your build configurations alongside your source code, making it easier to reproduce and track changes in your build process.

4. Build Steps and Customization: Cloud Build allows you to define custom build steps to perform specific actions during the build process. You can execute scripts, run tests, install dependencies, and perform other build tasks. This flexibility enables you to customize your build process to meet your specific requirements.

5. Integration with Google Cloud Platform: Cloud Build integrates tightly with other Google Cloud Platform services, such as Container Registry, Kubernetes Engine, and App Engine. It simplifies the process of building and deploying containerized applications to Google Cloud, leveraging the platform’s features and capabilities.

6. Build Triggers and Automatic Builds: Cloud Build provides build triggers that allow you to set up automatic builds based on specific events or conditions. For example, you can configure a trigger to initiate a build whenever a new commit is pushed to a specific branch in your repository.

7. Build Logs and Monitoring: Cloud Build offers detailed build logs and monitoring capabilities, allowing you to track the progress and status of your builds. You can view build logs in real-time, monitor build durations, and diagnose build failures or errors.

Overall, Cloud Build focuses on the build process and integration with CI/CD pipelines, providing a managed and scalable build environment with additional features like build triggers, build customization, and integration with Google Cloud Platform services. It complements Docker by providing a streamlined and automated way to build and deploy containerized applications in a cloud-native environment.

In summary, Docker is a containerization platform that allows you to create, manage, and run containers, while Cloud Build is a build service that helps automate the build process, including the creation of container images, within a cloud environment. They can complement each other, with Docker being used for local development and deployment scenarios, and Cloud Build providing a managed build service for cloud-based build workflows.

—

So, this means that Cloud Build can do what Docker can do – it can create images, package them, and store them. But Docker has more features and functionalities that aren’t necessary but nice to have, whereas Cloud Build provides an abstracted infrastructure that can scale effectively.

I hope this has helped you understand Docker and Cloud Build. If you have any questions, feel free to comment below.

Cheers.